The Teaching of Listening
Hacettepe University (Beytepe-Ankara, Turkey)
arifs [at] hun. edu. tr
Listening is the ability to identify and understand what others are saying. This involves understanding a speaker's accent or pronunciation, his grammar and his vocabulary, and grasping his meaning (Howatt and Dakin). An able listener is capable of doing these four things simultaneously. Willis (1981:134) lists a series of micro-skills of listening, which she calls enabling skills. They are:
- predicting what people are going to talk about
- guessing at unknown words or phrases without panic
- using one's own knowledge of the subject to help one understand
- identifying relevant points; rejecting irrelevant information
- retaining relevant points (note-taking, summarizing)
- recognizing discourse markers, e. g. , Well; Oh, another thing is; Now, finally; etc.
- understanding different intonation patterns and uses of stress, etc. , which give clues to meaning and social setting
- understanding inferred information, e. g. , speakers' attitude or intentions.
recognizing cohesive devices, e. g. , such as and which, including linking words, pronouns, references, etc.
Listening to and understanding speech involves a number of basic processes, some depending upon linguistic competence, some depending upon previous knowledge that is not necessarily of a purely linguistic nature, and some depending upon psychological variables that affect the mobilization of these competence and knowledge in the particular task situation. The listener must have a continuous set to listen and understand, and as he hears the utterance, he may be helped by some kind of set to process and remember the information transmitted. His linguistic competence enables him, presumably, to recognize the formatives of the heard utterance, i. e. , to dissect out of the wave form of the morphemes, words, and other meaning-bearing elements of the utterance.
Listening is a receptive skill, and receptive skills give way to productive skills. If we have our students produce something, the teaching will be more communicative. This brings us to the must of integrating language skills. There are two reasons for using integrating activities in language classrooms:
- To practice and extend the learners' use of a certain language structure or function
- To develop the learners' ability in the use of two or more of the skills within real contexts and communicative frame work.
Integrated activities, on the other hand, provide a variety in the classroom and thus maintain motivation and allow the recycling and revision of language which has already been taught separately in each skill.
How can we be certain that listening experiences will become more productive? Wittich tells us to distinguish the four levels existing in listening to radio or recordings:
- Level 1. This mood is listening. Here, the sound remains in the background - there is usually limited comprehension, and, indeed, limited attention. One becomes directly aware of sounds only when they stop. Nevertheless, a certain amount of learning may take place.
- Level 2. Here the purpose is relaxation, escape, getting your mind off something rather than on it. The material is comprehended but usually not analyzed for its value. This listening may result in useful ideas, but they are usually peripheral and/or accidental.
- Level 3. On this level, answers are sought as a key to action. One listens to weather reports, traffic information from a plane-temporarily useful but what we might call forgettable transient information. This form of listening does not require long, sustained concentration.
- Level 4. This is the stage of analytical and critical listening. The listener not only seeks a serious answer to a serious question but evaluates the quality of the answer. Round-table discussions, serious listening to talks, spirited conversation, symphonic music are at the fourth level. At this stage, listening to music is in the foreground of attention not in the background as on previous levels (Wittich and Schuller, 1962).
- Adopt a positive attitude.
- Be responsive.
- Shut out distractions.
- Listen for the speaker's purpose.
- Look for the signals of what is to come.
- Look for summaries of what has gone before.
- Evaluate the supporting materials.
- Look for non-verbal clues.
- (I) recognised as meaningful and understood on perception
- (II) held in the short term memory long enough to be decoded
- (III) related to what has gone before and /or what follows.
- Perception of sounds, letter shapes, etc.
- Initial recognition of meaning of short stretches
- Material held in short term memory
- Related to material already held in short term memory
- Related to material arriving in short-term memory
- Meaning extracted from message and retained in long-term memory
- Gist recalled later
- Pre-listening (purpose must be given at this stage),
- During (in-while) listening,
- Post -listening (speaking).
In listening activities, we listen for a purpose. We make an immediate response to what we hear. There are some visual or environmental clues as to the meaning of what is heard. Stretches of heard discourse come in short chunks, and most heard discourse is spontaneous, therefore differs from formal spoken prose in the amount of redundancy 'noise' and colloquialisms, and its auditory character.
In listening to English as a foreign language, the most important features can be defined as:
- Coping with the sounds,
- Understanding intonation and stress,
- Coping with redundancy and noise,
- Understanding colloquial vocabulary,
- Understanding different accents,
- Using visual and environmental clues.
We can divide listening for comprehension into three stages;
- Listening and making no response (following a written text, informal teacher talk)
- Listening and making short responses (obeying instructions - physical movement, building models, picture dictation. etc.), true- false exercises, noting specific information, etc.
- Listening and making longer response (repetition and dictation, paraphrasing, answering questions, answering comprehension questions on texts, predictions, filling gaps, summarizing, etc)
- General information (understanding of the main points)
- Specific information (understanding of the particular items)
- Cultural interest (generally informing about the target language culture)
- Information about people's attitudes and opinions
- The organization of ideas
- Sequence of events
- Lexical items (words expressing noise / movement)
- Structural items (their use and meaning)
- Functional items (their form and use)
In order to teach listening skills, a teacher should firstly state the difficulties. For a student of a foreign language, accurate and intelligent listening is a necessity, and the teacher is responsible to help his / her learners to acquire this skill which provides the very foundation for learning and functioning in a language. That the teacher can observe and isolate the errors in speaking, but could not in listening is a difficulty. In listening, the learner can exercise no controls over the structural and lexical range of the speaker to whom he is listening. Nevertheless, any listener can learn to focus on significant content items, to explain in another way he can learn to listen selectively.
Helping the learners to distinguish sounds, teaching to isolate significant content and informational items for concentration may be provided by controlled listening exercises. One exercise is to give him certain performance objectives -to give him general informational questions that he should be able to answer after he listens the material for the first time. These questions should require only the isolation of facts clearly revealed in the material. Questions that require application or inference from the information contained in the listening exercise are best used at later stages or more advanced students.
More controls are necessary at less advanced levels. Sheets containing sequentially organized and significant questions on context and content -questions that call for one-word answers -serve as useful guides for the student. Such questions help him filter out and listen for significant information. The questions themselves suggest the content and provide the student with an organizational frame for selective listening.
For listening comprehension exercises, we tend to read passages, record news or broadcasts, or prepare lectures. All of them have value, but they are extremely difficult sources for early practice in selective listening. This type of listening exercises does not present the redundancies, the colloquialisms, the hesitations, the gestures and the facial expressions that are an inseparable part of the spoken language. They emphasize informational content and fail to provide the signals used to communicate information and meaning.
Since most of the actual listening the student will be exposed to outside of the class is likely to be real-life conversation, it seems wisest to use materials cast in real-life situations for listening comprehension exercises -at least at the beginning level. If the oral instruction of the course is contextualized -set into a " situation " - it should be easy enough to contextualize the aural practice as well. The teacher can easily adapt to listening exercises those situations through which the text presents oral drills and communicative activities, just by giving them a slightly different twist. Listening exercises should be as natural as the situations from which they grow. In other words, an exercise in listening comprehension must be as close as possible to a "slice of life" -neither a contrived situation nor an artificially delivered discourse. By means of this, a teacher has a great work to do, and has to be a very creative person in order to teach listening communicatively.
Lesson PlanTopic: Beauty Contest
Duration: 20 minutes
Level: Upper Intermediate
Materials: Pictures, blackboard, tape, tape-recorder
Goals: Students are asked to understand when they listen to a speech. This lesson will at least make the students take one step to get accustomed to hearing and understanding what they hear. Objectives: By the end of the lesson the students will understand the significance of listening.
Pre-listening Activities: The teacher asks the students what they are going to listen to. A discussion atmosphere is tried to be created. At this stage pictures are used effectively.
During Listening Activities: While students are listening to the tape the teacher asks them to take some notes.
Post-listening Activities: The teacher writes some questions on the board and asks them to answer the questions. They are also stimulated to talk and participate in the activity dominantly.
I. PRE-LISTENIG ACTIVITIES
The teacher hangs the pictures on the board and tries to make the students talk about the subjects.
T: Do you think that they are beautiful?
S:. . .
T: Can you guess the name of the first competitor?
S:. . .
T: Can you guess the height of the second competitor?
S:. . .
T: What nationality does the third girl belong to? What is your opinion?
S:. . .
II. DURING LISTENING ACTIVITIES
The teacher asks the students to listen to the tape very carefully. And he gives information lists to the students. While they are listening to the tape they try to fill the blanks with appropriate information. If no information appears for any blank on the list, students are asked to put a cross on the blank provided for the required information.
III. POST-LISTENING ACTIVITY
The teacher writes on the board some questions. Students answer these questions to test whether they understood what they have listened or not.
- Whose name is the best? Why do you think so?
- Who is the tallest one of all?
- Who is the oldest one of all?
- Who is the heaviest one of all?
- What nationality does the first one belong to?
- What nationality does the second one belong to?
- What nationality does the third one belong to?
- Who can speak two languages?
- What are those languages?
- Whose favorite film star is Leonardo Di Caprio?
- What does Suzanne Kerrigan mean by saying" I hope the political situation of my country will not effect this kind of a contest?"
At home listen to the information about the people whose names are in the chart below and copmlete the missing information.
|Elizabeth Mccornick||Alexandra Bellomonti||Suzanne Kerrigan|
|Nationality: Canadian||Nationality: Italian||Nationality:|
|Weight: 53||Weight: 51||Weight: 56|
|Age: 21||Age: 20 years old||Age: 22|
|Her mother's name:|
- I'm Elizabeth Mccornick. I'm participating from Canada. I'm 21 years old and I weigh 53 kilos. I am a girl of 90-60-90. I am a bilingual person; that means I can speak two languages fluently and accurately: English and French. I prefer going to movies than enjoying theatrical acts. My favorite film star is Leonardo Di Caprio. My friends say that I am a good cook as well. I admit I like cooking traditional dishes in my spare time. I wish my best wishes to the other contestants. Thanks.
- Good evening! I would like to greet all the people watching and participating this contest. My name is Alexandra Bellomonti and I'm from Italy. I am 20 years old and 51 kilos I weigh. I like going out with my friends at the weekends. I can also say that I'm studying really hard and I am expecting to be accepted to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. I really have a great desire for being a genetic engineer in the future. Thank you!
- Hello everybody! I am Suzanne Kerrigan from the USA. I was born in 1976, in LA, California. I confess I weigh 56 kilos but I'm 1. 73 cm tall and that subdues my weight I think. I like skating on ice and I'm an amateur figure skater. I also like foreign and strange meals if they prove to be delicious, of course. Finally, I hope the political situation of my country will not effect this kind of a contest
- Abbott, G. & P. Wingard. (1985). The Teaching of English as an International Language: A Practical Guide. Great Britain.
- Austin S. . (1970). Speaking & Listening:A Contemporary Approach. Harcourt, Brace & World, Inc. USA
- Carroll E. R. (1969). The Learning of Language. National Council of Teachers of English Publication. New York.
- Celce Å\Murcia, M. & L. mcIntosh. (1979). Teaching English as a Second or Foreign Language. Newbury House Publishers, Inc. Massachusetts.
- Fox J. W. (1974). Teaching Listening Skills. English Teaching Forum. October -- December, 12, pp. 42-45
- Joiner, E. (1977). Communicative Activities for Beginning Language Students. English Teaching Forum, April, 15, pp. 8-9.
- Yagang, F. (1993). Listening: Problems and Solutions, , English Teaching Forum, January 31, pp. 16-19.
The Internet TESL Journal, Vol. V, No. 12, December 1999